When a work is deemed one made for hire, authorship is attributed not to the original creator of the work, but to the employer of the author or the commissioner of the work. One of the most common misconceptions about law is that if you pay someone to develop software for you, it is a work made for hire and. Now, however, the standards for establishing work made for hire are much more stringent. Therefore even if the work a commissioning party wishes to claim ownership interest in falls. The distinction between an employee and an independent contractor is governed by the rules of agency law and is frequently a factspecific issue. The workmadeforhire doctrine generally defines the relationship between a software developer and his or her client. For this reason, these agreements are often used when hiring writers and artists for projects. Work made for hire doctrine does not generally apply to. The designation of a work as a work made for hire also can have an effect on termination rights.
First, if you are a regular employee, your employer will own any work you do within the scope of your employment automatically as work made for hire. Only certain kinds of work actually qualify as a work for hire under the statute. How to protect your intellectual property rights in works. For other types of creative works, you will have to use an assignment. In both cases, the software is the property of the employing company. In 1977, the supreme court of india clarified that the producer would be the first owner of a work made for hire under section 17. A segment of software code is a workmadeforhire if it is either. Rather, the employer or party who commissioned the work obtains these rights. Work made for hire doctrine does not generally apply to computer. February 3, 2016, the court found in dicta that work performed by an independent contractor in creating a software program for. Works created by independent contractors can only constitute. The second, the workmadeforhire doctrine wmfh under law, allocates ownership and attribution for able works to the employer of the naturalperson authoreven where that employer is a nonnatural, legal person such as a corporation. In the realm of law, works for hire is a term that refers to the general situation in which a creator of a work, who would otherwise retain rights in the work, gives up rights in the work.
Potential pitfalls under the work for hire doctrine. Under the reid test, the work for hire doctrine now excludes many works that might have qualified as work for hire under previous standards. The best approach is to include an appropriate intellectual property assignment in the contract, assigning the deliverables from the independent contractor to the hiring company. A specific paragraph in the case is reproduced hereunder. If a work is made for hire, an employer is considered the author even if an employee actually created the work. As applied in an employeremployee situation, there is no debate that computer software can be a work made for hire. The work made for hire doctrine maintains that an employer will own all exclusive rights to the work made by employees. In the law of the united states, a work made for hire work for hire or wfh is a work subject to that is created by an employee as part of his or her job, or some limited types of works for which all parties agree in writing to the wfh designation. The work for hire doctrine as it applies to software programs is still very much unsettled law, and works created by independent contractors will arguably become works made for hire only under very specific, defined circumstances and with a lot of help from your agreements with your independent contractors. As a rule, hiring parties prefer to obtain rights on work for hire basis shorthand for work made for hire.
In the case of a work made for hire, the employer or other person for whom the work was prepared is considered the author for purposes of this. Computer software as a work made for hire henryparklaw. A work made fore hire can occur in two separate ways. The work made for hire sometimes abbreviated to work for hire or wfh doctrine is an exception to the general rule that the person who actually creates a work is the legallyrecognized author of that work. The ninth circuit held that the work made for hire doctrine would apply if usap could show 1 thomason was an employee of partsbinusap. Works made for hire and film production bananaip counsels. There are a couple of distinct ways that a work will. The determination of whether an individual is an employee for the purposes of the work made for hire doctrine is determined under the common law of. Common misconception of ownership under the work for hire. Startup and technology employees and the use of contracts in a hiring relationship. A work for hire agreement may also be used to ensure that the contractor doesnt retain any rights over the product or the work created.
China patents, copyrights, and works made for hire china. Leavitt one of the most common misconceptions about law is that if you pay someone to develop software for you, it is a work made for hire and you own it. A software program created by a staff programmer within the scope of his or her duties at a software firm. And, yet, there are many examples of companies hiring an independent software developer to develop code under a work for hire agreement, and it is later determined that the written agreement did not adequately assign rights to the specially made software to the company. The doctrine work made for hire deals with the ownership of intellectual propertyip right between the employer or hirer contextually each of them hereinafter referred to as owner and author or inventor or creator, or patentee or grantee contextually each of them hereinafter referred to as creator wherein the creator relinquishes or transfers hisher ownership rights in. A work made for hire is 1 a work prepared by an employee within the scope of his or her employment. Works made for hire in the united states the workmadeforhire doctrine governs authorship of able works by employees and independent contractors. Conceptually, the basis of the work made for hire often shortened to work for hire doctrine is clear. Without a formal agreement in place, rights may not be transferred to the client who purchased the work. Note that a computer program developed by a contractor can never be a work for hire, because computer programs are not one of the nine categories. Under the current statute, there are only two ways that the work made for hire doctrine can apply to graphic artists. Make sure the written work made for hire agreement is signed by both parties before the creation of the work. Copyrights and the work for hire doctrine the ip law blog.
The southern district of new york finds work made for. The work made for hire status of a work will effect the length of protection and termination rights as discussed below. In fact, the work for hire doctrine rarely if ever applies to the types of deliverables prepared under these types of contracts. In sum, this case illustrates three different ways that an employer can obtain software. Works prepared by an employee within the scope of employment. Ownership issues underlying the work made for hire. The work made for hire doctrine started in the courts and. Examples of works made for hire created in an employment relationship include. Although the term work made for hire is nowhere to be found in the statutes or legal jurisprudence of most other countries, the morricone decision is not an outlier among cases dealing with the legal effect of foreign authorship when pursuing statutory rights granted under u. Siniouguine, the plaintiff, had been employed by mediachase, the defendant.
Copyright, computer software, and work made for hire. If the creation of the work falls outside the scope of employment the employee, and not the publisher, would have ownership of the work. However, when commissioning works from independent contractors, additional steps need to be taken to ensure the employer obtains full rights to the work. Many contracts still use work made for hire language left over from that time. Define your role with a work made for hire agreement. A work of the united states government is a work prepared by an officer or employee of the united states government as part of that persons official duties. It is not, however, one of the enumerated categories of works that qualifies as a work for hire in the statute. Works created by independent contractors can only constitute worksforhire if. Under the work made for hire doctrine, however, ownership transfers from the author to the company that has commissioned it. It then analyzes the case law interpreting the work made for hire provisions of the 1976 act and considers the likely results of dis putes over ownership under the various interpreta tions. A work made for hire is 1 a work prepared by an employee within the.
For certain types of creative works called works for hire, you will own the as long as you and the ic execute a written workforhire agreement. The significance of this doctrine is that, as the owner of the work, an employer will own all exclusive rights to the work and may freely commercialize the property to its fullest. It then analyzes the case law interpreting the work. With a work for hire, the hiring party steps into the shoes of the creator and becomes the author of the work for purposes. First, if you are a regular employee, your employer will. Among other things, the court held that the software was specially commissioned and qualified as a work made for hire as contributions to a collective. Work for hire is any created work that can be ed like songs, stories, essays, sculptures, paintings, graphic designs, or computer programs. In the law of the united states, a work made for hire is a work subject to that. Note that even should a commissioned work fall within one of the categories, the statute raises a further barrier to the application of the work for hire doctrine. Among other things, the court held that the software was specially commissioned and qualified as a work made for hire as contributions to a collective work and compilations. Works made for hire are possible in in two types of relationships. Nonprofits and the work made for hire doctrine charity.
Courts also have found computer software made by an independent contractor to be a contribution to a collective work for purposes of the work made for hire doctrine. This article describes the realities of software development and the history of the work made for hire doctrine. Computer software as a work made for hire henry park law. A work not made for hire is ordinarily protected by for the life of the author plus 70 years.
In general, the legal rights that exist by virtue of law lodge and vest in the author or authors of any creative work and those rights vest at the moment of creation. Theres a bit of mystery surrounding the work made for hire doctrine, especially when it comes to independent contractors that develop software. Because of the legal technicalities associated with the work for hire doctrine as applied to independent contractors, any reference to a work for hire is both unnecessary and possibly dangerous. However, under the work made for hire doctrine, ownership flows to the employer or the person for whom the work is prepared because they are considered to be the author. It is surprising how many software development contracts with independent contractors rely on a designation of deliverables as works for hire to give the customer ownership of s in the deliverables. In practical terms, hiring parties that commission work have lost the ability to designate such work as work for hire for all but a few, narrow categories of work. However, under the work made for hire doctrine, ownership flows to the employer or the person for whom the work is prepared because. In other words, heshe would be the first owner of the works made for hire. The employer can be a firm, an organization, or an individual. Work made for hire doctrine does not generally apply to computer software by james g. For example, it is a common misconception that software qualifies as a work for hire. Include an appropriate assignment clause in the work made for hire agreement that will serve as a backup if the work does not qualify as a work made for hire.
1318 628 1424 794 560 717 9 699 571 762 545 1071 690 306 649 99 406 895 455 305 922 1075 1514 412 1031 1357 876 491 354 225 469 1094 123 790